Does The VOOM Trial Settlement Show That Dish Network Was Shrewd To Drop AMC?

Sure looks that way — for the company, not Dish Network subscribers. AMC Networks shares are +3.9% in early trading following yesterday’s $700M agreement with Dish Network to settle the $2.4B breach of contract case involving the defunct VOOM suite of HD channels. But the surprise is that Dish is up 2.2%. Consider that a sigh of relief from shareholders who feared the worst from the lousy hand chairman Charlie Ergen had to play in court. A series of rulings by New York Supreme Court Judge Richard Lowe III found that Dish destroyed or covered up important evidence that probably would have hurt its case — and made Dish a likely loser against the charge that in 2008 it wrongly terminated its 15-year deal deal to carry VOOM. Yet Ergen’s decision in June to drop the AMC channels appears to have paid off. The $700M settlement was “well below Street expectations” of at least $1B says Wells Fargo Securities’ Marci Ryvicker. Barclays Equity Research’s James Ratcliffe calls the amount “quite reasonable” in light of the court setbacks. (more…)

This article was printed from