The theater industry’s pandemic-shortened season seems to have opened up the Grammy playing field for cast albums, as only two of the six just-announced nominees for the 2021 awards represent the usually-dominant Broadway.
The two Broadway cast albums included in today’s nominations for Best Musical Theater Album are David Byrne’s American Utopia on Broadway and Jagged Little Pill, the musical consisting of Alanis Morissette songs. Two London cast albums were nominated (Amélie, The Prince of Egypt), as were two from Off Broadway (Little Shop of Horrors, Soft Power).
Last year, all five nominees in the category were Broadway productions (Hadestown won), while the year before Broadway accounted for four of the five nominees, with TV’s Jesus Christ Superstar Live in Concert filling out the category (Broadway’s The Band’s Visit won). Previous years show a similar pro-Broadway pattern.
A slew of highly anticipated 2020 Broadway musicals were either postponed due to the Covid-19 shutdown last March or had not yet recorded Broadway cast albums. They include Caroline, Or Change starring Sharon D. Clarke, Company starring Patti LuPone, the Princess Di musical Diana, Mrs. Doubtfire, Six and the West Side Story revival. Both Caroline, Or Change and Tina: The Tina Turner Musical already have cast albums from earlier London productions (a Broadway Tina album isn’t in the works), and both Sing Street and Girl From The North Country have recorded Broadway 2020 cast albums, with Sing Street currently available digitally, with pre-orders being taken for an audio CD (Amazon is listing a June 18, 2021 availability). For North Country, the musical of Bob Dylan songs, the 2018 London cast recording is available.
Of course, it’s a fool’s errand to play What If about the Grammy-worthiness of unrecorded or unreleased cast albums, even for musicals that had already revealed their goods on stage before the pandemic (West Side Story and Girl From The North Country, at the very least, would no doubt have been in Grammy contention).
Muddying the speculation even more is the fact that so many of this year’s non-Broadway Grammy nominees are more than worthy of the competition. Amélie was the better reviewed of the two London productions, while the Public Theater’s Off Broadway staging of Soft Power received mixed reviews overall but favorable notices for the Jeanine Tesori score. The West Side Theatre’s Little Shop of Horrors starring Jonathan Groff and Tammy Blanchard won universal raves.
So, here goes another fool’s errand: I’d put David Byrne’s American Utopia, Jagged Little Pill and Little Shop of Horrors in a final three breakdown, with the unstoppable former Talking Head burning down the house, or taking it to the river. Winning.
The Grammys ceremony is set for Sunday, January 31 live on CBS with Trevor Noah to host.
Here are this year’s Best Musical Theater Album nominees:
Audrey Brisson, Chris Jared, Caolan McCarthy & Jez Unwin, principal soloists; Michael Fentiman, Sean Patrick Flahaven, Barnaby Race & Nathan Tysen, producers; Nathan Tysen, lyricist; Daniel Messe, composer & lyricist (Original London Cast)
AMERICAN UTOPIA ON BROADWAY
David Byrne, principal soloist; David Byrne, producer (David Byrne, composer & lyricist) (Original Cast)
JAGGED LITTLE PILL
Kathryn Gallagher, Celia Rose Gooding, Lauren Patten & Elizabeth Stanley, principal soloists; Neal Avron, Pete Ganbarg, Tom Kitt, Michael Parker, Craig Rosen & Vivek J. Tiwary, producers (Glen Ballard & Alanis Morissette, lyricists) (Original Broadway Cast)
LITTLE SHOP OF HORRORS
Tammy Blanchard, Jonathan Groff & Tom Alan Robbins, principal soloists; Will Van Dyke, Michael Mayer, Alan Menken & Frank Wolf, producers (Alan Menken, composer; Howard Ashman, lyricist) (The New Off-Broadway Cast)
THE PRINCE OF EGYPT
Christine Allado, Luke Brady, Alexia Khadime & Liam Tamne, principal soloists; Dominick Amendum & Stephen Schwartz, producers; Stephen Schwartz, composer & lyricist (Original Cast)
Francis Jue, Austin Ku, Alyse Alan Louis & Conrad Ricamora, principal soloists; Matt Stine, producer; David Henry Hwang, lyricist; Jeanine Tesori, composer & lyricist (Original Cast)