Part one of The Bachelor Season 24 finale ended Monday night with tears and a twist few people saw coming.
Peter said he was confused and confessed, “I am in love with two different women.”
Hannah Ann quickly won over Peter’s parents, with his mom calling her “loving and caring.” His dad thought she was “remarkable.”
Peter appeared to be leaning toward Madison. Although his mom warned him not to let Hannah Ann get away.
“Hannah Ann loves you with all of her heart,” his mom said.
Peter’s response: “You guys just don’t know the Maddie I know.” His family wasn’t convinced. But Madison ultimately made the decision for him.
The two went on a picnic for their final date and Madison dumped him! “I don’t know, we see things so differently,” she explained. At times fighting back tears, she said their relationship really came into focus the last time they were together and made her realize they were in different places “when it comes to marriage, when it comes to faith, when it comes to lifestyle.”
They shared one last hug before he put her in an SUV and watched her drive off. On the ride home, she said she knew it was “the right thing to do.”
The next day a devastated Peter got a visit from Chris Harrison and admitted he was heartbroken about Madison leaving. But apparently all wasn’t lost because Peter said he’s still “in love with” Hannah Ann.
The second part of the finale airs tomorrow night on ABC.