You might not want to get into a bathtub anytime soon after watching this latest teaser for WGN America’s Salem Season 2. Appropriately titled “Bloodbath” it features Salem’s deadliest witch Mary Sibley (Janet Montgomery) and her shadowy accomplice Tibuba (Ashley Madekwe) who return for the second season in the heat of a witch war. The series is currently in production in Shreveport, LA on its 13-episode sophomore run. Salem Season 2 premieres Sunday, April 5 at 10 PM ET/ 9 PM CT on WGN America. Check out the teaser above.