A New York judge has tossed the yearlong legal action around the short-lived paranormal crime series. “The Court finds that no discerning observer would conclude that Past Life had appropriated protected elements from Transience,” wrote Judge Barbara Jones yesterday (read ruling here). Transience writer Stevan Mena sued Fox Entertainment, Warner Bros Entertainment as well as producers David Hudgins and Craig Perry for copyright infringement last August. Produced by Warner Bros Television, Past Life debuted on February 9, 2010. With low ratings, Fox cancelled the show after three episodes. The screenwriter claimed that significant elements of the TV series were drawn from the script he wrote back in 2008. For instance, both do feature reincarnation, a child who has visions and is taken care of by a doctor and crime. However the judge ruled that there’s nothing unique about such story devices. Mena contends that his feature script made its way to Past Life creator Hudgins via Practical Pictures’ Perry and was the basis for the show. Guy Cohen and C. Andrew Keisner of New York’s Davis & Gilbert represented Mena. Craig Perry was represented by Stephen Kramarsky of Dewey, Pegno & Kramarsky Warner Bros, Fox and David Hudgins were represented by Andrew Bart and Andrew Thomas of New York’s Jenner Block.

Related: Dick Wolf & David Hudgins To Adapt British Series ‘Injustice’ For NBC