Megan Masters is West Coast Editor at TVLine

Boardwalk EmpireHaving portrayed some of Hollywood’s fiercest funny women, Christina Applegate has never shined or elicited as many laughs as she did this season on NBC’s freshman comedy Up All Night. The Emmy-seasoned actress (winning in 2003 and nominated again in 2004 for her guest-starring role as Rachel’s sister on Friends and later receiving two lead actress nominations for Samantha Who?) drew inspiration from her own personal experiences to bring life to Reagan Brinkley, a smart, witty and grounded working mom. Might Emmy voters once again reward Applegate? The TV vet is modest when it comes to discussing her own odds, but isn’t shy about showering her co-stars (Will Arnett and Maya Rudolph in particular) with praise.

AWARDSLINE: You’ve starred in many comedies throughout your career, but Up All Night’s Reagan seems to stand out as the most… you.
CHRISTINA APPLEGATE: Reagan greatly differs from everything I’ve done – Samantha Who?, Anchorman and [Married With Children‘s] Kelly Bundy… She’s the closest to me than anything I’ve ever done. They actually write [Reagan] a lot from having conversations with me, from her core beliefs to the rhythmic way in which she speaks. In that way, it’s a much easier job than I’ve ever had.

Related: EMMYS: Comedy Series Overview

AWARDSLINE: So, come clean: Are you as crazy-competitive as Reagan?
APPLEGATE: Yes! [Laughs] Everyone in my life thinks I’m competitive because I want to win, but it comes from me wanting everyone to have a good time. And when I see that people aren’t enthused, I try to make it really uncomfortable for everyone so they get enthused and want to play hard.

AWARDSLINE: Traditionally in television, the ‘competitive’ woman is also the ‘bitchy’ woman. And yet with Reagan, it’s endearing and something that her husband actually embraces.
APPLEGATE: A lot of times when you see couples on TV, the comedy comes out of them fighting and bickering. We wanted to show a different kind of partnership, which is that they’re best friends. It’s very similar to what [creator] Emily [Spivey] and her husband have. … The funniest scenes between Chris and Reagan are when they are a quirky little team – and they’re a little nerdy! [Laughs]

AWARDSLINE: You come from a traditional acting background, while your co-stars have pasts in improvisation. Would you say that’s an advantage? Or do you feel more pressure to be funny?
APPLEGATE: Will and Maya do improv a lot. It’s just not something I’m as comfortable [with] as they are. But it’s great to watch and I’ve learned a lot from both of them. There have been a lot of things that have just come out of my mouth that have ended up in the show off the cuff. I try to get in there. Most of the time writers can be incredibly precious with their words and you don’t want to mess with it too much – in fact, they don’t like it – but [on Up All Night] they do like it. If you can improve upon it, then by all means do so. I always like the page to be really good, though.

AWARDSLINE: The show also had a number of big-name guest stars in Season 1. Do you think that helped keep things fresh?
APPLEGATE: We love it. We love when [the show is] simple and just us, but we really love when someone else comes in that we get the opportunity to work with. I was so thrilled to have Blythe [Danner] play my mother. She was the only person I wanted from Day 1. I said, ‘Call her, that’s the person I want. I don’t know what we have to do, but get her out here and make sure she is my mother.’ [Laughs] There was also Megan [Mullally] who I’ve always wanted to work with, so that was really a joy… and Molly [Shannon] too. And then we have someone come in and surprise us, like Chris Diamantopoulos, who played Julian. After he left, we said that we had to have him back – a lot! And he ended up providing a great deal of comedy for the show.

AWARDSLINE: Looking back on the season, what would you say are Will and Maya’s Emmy-worthy moments?
APPLEGATE: I always enjoy scenes between Maya and Chris. And there’s one where she’s driving her own limousine and she keeps messing up the windows; it was just really well performed. If and when she gets nominated for an Emmy – which, if anyone from the show is going to, it’s going to be Maya – that should be her submission. And Will is funny in every episode, so he could pretty much put any of them in.

AWARDSLINE: What about a standout moment for Reagan?
APPLEGATE: Hmmm, those are harder to find… [Laughs] I was really proud of ‘Birth.’ I enjoyed doing that episode and thought that they really got my character.

AWARDSLINE: And we can’t talk Emmy-caliber performances without mentioning Carly and Delaney Prince, the toddler twins who play your daughter, Amy.
APPLEGATE: Ours would win an Emmy, hands down! They put all the other babies to shame, I’m sorry. We all lose our shit when they do what they do… They amaze us. [They] should win a Baby Emmy.