Forever creator Matt Miller took to Twitter to answer fans’ questions about what would have been had there been a second go-round for the canceled ABC supernatural drama, and what would have become of Henry and Jo.

As you’ll recall the final episode wrapped with immortal doctor Henry Morgan (Ioan Gruffudd) finally ready to tell a puzzled NYPD Detective Jo Martinez (Alana de la Garza) his secret after she saw a photo and noticed he hadn’t aged in decades. Here’s a sampling of a few of the questions and Miller’s responses: