UPDATE: Here's Our Favorite Comment About The Treacherous Business Of Ending A TV Series

UPDATED, 2 PM: We have a winner in the Best Comment About Series Finales Sweepstakes. Not only does Deadline reader D. have some solid choices about TV shows with memorable wrap-ups, he or she makes a quite valid point: Why watch “bad TV” anyway? As for the commenter’s spectacular prize — “IT’S A BEAUTIFUL, BRAND-NEW … uh, nothing. Nada. Nichts. Bupkiss. But thanks for playing our game…

D. says:

Seeing as how everyone’s doing this, I figured I’d chime in:

Best Series Finales: The Sopranos, The Wire, Friday Night Lights, Breaking Bad

Worst: Haven’t seen enough bad TV, but I reckon True Blood will be up there.

HONORABLE MENTION:

terrence says:

How do you not mention the “The Mary Tyler Moore Show” finale episode — which truly set the standard for series finales that has only been met by the “Newhart” finale?

And splitting the final season of “Mad Men” over two years was a big mistake on the part of AMC. It worked for “Breaking Bad” for a number of organic reasons that “Mad Men” doesn’t have the benefit of.

PREVIOUSLY, August 5: A version of this story on TV series finales appeared in the most recent issue of Awardsline. From Breaking Bad and How I Met Your Mother to True Blood and Sons Of Anarchy, a number of shows have ended or are ending their run this year, so take a trip to some goodbyes here and then tell us what you think have been the best and the worst TV series finales. We’ll announce a winner later this week.

On television, as in life, the exit rather than the entrance often is what forms our memories of things. TV series finales, in particular, hold a special place of distinction in both the industry and the culture. A good ending can deepen one’s commitment, even postmortem, to a show, while a bad or negligible one can leave audience members feeling deep-sixed. Dexter is a prime example of how the way a show ends even can have Emmy impact. While Showtime’s serial-killer series enjoyed past Emmy love, including best drama noms from 2008 to 2011—and even experienced record show ratings for its finale last fall—it’s no secret its heat had dissipated. The Dexter-Morgan-still-lives ending failed to maximize the show’s last shot at redemption and was dead with Television Academy voters. There were zero nominations this time around.

A good finale is hard to define, and getting it right is something that can elude even the most celebrated networks and creators. It’s not just a matter of closing the door on an iconic set and turning off the lights. Here are some of the more recent ways several series have met their ends.

Related: Some Of This Year’s Emmy Contenders Are Gorier Than Ever

The Main Event
True Blood Season 7“I think we feel that the right thing is always to end (a show) with some creative integrity so the viewers feel satisfied and the creators feel satisfied,” HBO programming president Michael Lombardo said at this summer’s TCAs. He knows a thing or two about goodbyes. HBO has made an art of eventizing its series finales, what with all the endless reminders that the final season of the cabler’s True Blood is upon us. Although The Sopranos’ ambiguous ending left many viewers feeling ripped off and disappointed, there’s no denying it was the cultural event of 2007. People who never had seen a prior episode of the show tuned in. Even now, in clear retrospect, there appears to be a real method to creator David Chase’s Journey-soundtracked, cut-to-black madness. Like the tortured soul of the show itself, the space opened by that final scene left everything out there. It just took time to find it.

Will HBO’s Boardwalk Empire, which was created by former Sopranos writer Terence Winter, take the same approach when it concludes at the end of this year? Is that even a fair expectation? Well, yes, if you consider that conceived of as an event, finales always have been great promotions for broadcasters, and HBO will take full advantage of the opportunity afforded by the Prohibition-era drama’s end.

The AMC Effect
Treacherous Business of Season Finales on TVAMC’s double-your-luck strategy of splitting its big shows’ final seasons into two parts paid off again this year for Breaking Bad. Having snagged the best drama trophy last year with the first part of its fifth and final season, the blaze of bullets that ended the stunning Vince Gilligan series in September effectively built up the finale into enough of a cultural touchstone that the show’s Emmy history could repeat itself. Bad has been showered with 16 nominations for its swan song’s second half and looks to be the favorite to take the drama win again.

Under the same split-season edict and carnival barker ballyhoo Mad Men could find itself in a very similar position, even though the show’s creator Matthew Weiner has stated he tries to stand outside the business of the finale. Another Sopranos alumni, Weiner told me earlier this year that the final episode is “set in stone” and his big hope is that viewers next year will “walk away changed or better or at least entertained by it.”

Related: ‘Mad Men’ Mid-Season Finale Gets 1.9M Viewers

Disappearing Act
Image (4) communitypremiere__140103171846-275x183.jpg for post 658584The converse of the split season or spinoff ending is when a show is cancelled before a proper finale can be aired or even conceived, oftentimes resulting in a cliffhanger of the worst kind: one without hope of any resolution. Such was the case with NBC’s once-celebrated Revolution, whose plug was pulled at the end of Season 2 after a promising start. Not even co-creator J.J. Abrams could save it. The end, obviously a season finale now tasked with tying up storylines, lacked the emotional punch of a true sendoff. The Peacock network’s Community also was headed for the chopping block sans finale before it was curiously salvaged by Yahoo. Will creator Dan Harmon get the #SixSeasonsAndAMovie that he tweeted about in June? Here’s hoping he can end the show on his own terms.

Perfect Ending
The finale gold standard in many books is the 1990 ending to CBS’ Newhart. After years working as an innkeeper in Vermont, Bob Newhart’s Dick Loudon wakes up in the Chicago bedroom of the ’70s sitcom The Bob Newhart Show and tells his wife, played by Suzanne Pleshette, about the weird dream he had. “No more Japanese food before you go to bed,” she admonishes. The polishing touch was the credits from the elder Newhart show, and the witty rendition of “Oklahoma” from the 1978 finale, that ran at the end.

I’ve always been partial to the 2008 close of The Wire and Homicide: Life on the Street’s finale from 1999. The former because it was a conclusive and secure end, the latter because, suddenly cancelled by NBC after a seven-season run—and really only given a final season because the network had experienced Seinfeld’s controversial end the year before—the gritty drama displayed its characteristic brutal intelligence by bookending the series with a last scene that mirrored its first.

'True Detective' Finale and Why Season Finales Are a Treacherous BusinessThis is why True Detective’s season ender this spring was so fulfilling: It made sense within the construction of the HBO show for the circle to be complete. By following the anthology structure that has worked so well for FX’s American Horror Story, viewers will get the satisfaction of a complete story arc every season, an indirect homage to Rust Cohle with its TV version of Nietzsche’s Eternal Recurrence perhaps?

Image (1) How-I-Met-Your-Mother-finale__140401023805.jpg for post 706634Of course, there’s always the risk that a finale will go down in a blaze of disappointment and obscurity. While I’ve actually met people who say they liked it, there’s the sad, sad end of Seinfeld from 1998. We don’t need to open that wound again except to say that for what must have looked great on paper, the painful, “horrible people” end made the recent and almost equally hyped finale of How I Met Your Mother look good in comparison—nearly no one was happy with that sleight-of-hand swindle.

Related: ‘Sons of Anarchy’ Comic-Con Panel Preview Prequel, Season Finale

Never Say Never
It used to be that reruns were the only ways to relive our favorite show’s best moments, but spinoffs have taken off the past few years. Breaking Bad is over but will live and breathe in the body of the upcoming prequel series Better Call Saul, starring Bob Odenkirk. Even though FX’s biker drama Sons of Anarchy is slicing its way to a conclusion after seven seasons, creator Kurt Sutter still muses about giving it the movie or prequel treatment.

And four years after ending its eight-season run, 24 and Jack were back this spring. “I would have bet everything that Jack Bauer had seen his last day,” says executive producer Howard Gordon. And yet, Fox’s aptly titled limited event series, 24: Live Another Day, debuted for a 12-episode run in May. “The fact that (Jack) lived to see another day is testimony to how resilient this character is and how much we all missed him,” Gordon adds. But that’s one of the things about finales, isn’t it? Just because it’s over, doesn’t mean it’s ever really over—just ask Larry David.

The Good, The Bad And the Ugly
Series finales have run the gamut from perfect to pathetic. Here’s a look:

sopranos

Ample ambiguity: The Sopranos
The cut-to-black last scene of the finale left many wondering if Tony Soprano died in that diner.

 

o-BREAKING-BAD-FINALE-facebookBlaze of bullets: Breaking Bad
Walter White gets revenge and a smidge of redemption in this finale for the annals.

 

dexter finaleOff into the sunset?: Dexter
Serial killer Dexter Morgan’s life being spared at the end of this drama left some viewers nonplussed.

 

true detective finaleRust Cohle lives!: True Detective
Cohle and Marty Hart’s tender “odd couple” final moment touched viewers who were expecting something darker.

 

seinfeld finaleWah wah wah: Seinfeld
There was nothing too redeeming in the Seinfeld cast’s incarceration for violating a Good Samaritan law in the finale.

 

 

community finalePhoenix rising from the ashes: Community The comedy somehow has managed to live on, thanks to Yahoo, and will get its finale in due time.

 

revolution 2No Chance for goodbye: Revolution
The show’s Season 2 finale ended up being its series ender and was criticized for lacking an emotional punch.

 

wire finaleBack where it started: The Wire
The gritty, Baltimore-based drama was hailed for delivering a finale that was understated and honest–no fireworks or ticker-tape parade.

 

Last Forever Part OneIt was Robin all along: How I Met Your Mother
Fans didn’t like finally meeting the titular mom only to have her die and Ted rekindle his romance with Robin.

 

newhartA piece of perfection: Newhart
Newhart actually managed to pull off the “It was all a dream” trick ending, flashbacking to actor Bob Newhart’s 1970s sitcom.

 

Leno-Cheers-AP-1993-630x473Event of the season: Cheers
The long-running comedy’s finale was followed by a live taping of The Tonight Show, during which Jay Leno wrangled with a drunk, united cast.

 

lost-finaleWhat did it all mean?: Lost
The drama series was criticized for consistently being open-ended, and nowhere more so than its finale.

  1. The finale of Star Trek: The Next Generation was a high-point and got the syndicated show nominated for Best Drama Series.

  2. My pick would be the short-lived sitcom “I Married Dora.” The last scene of the last episode was set in an airport. Dora presumably got onto the plane, then suddenly came back and said, “It’s been cancelled.” “The flight?” “No, the series!” Then the entire cast waved good-bye to us as the camera pulled back, revealing the edges of the set.

  3. Best Finales: LOST, House, Desperate Housewives, Damages, FRIENDS.
    Worst Finale: 24 LAD, Dexter, How I Met Your Mother

  4. How do you not mention the “The Mary Tyler Moore Show” finale episode — which truly set the standard for series finales that has only been met by the “Newhart” finale?

    And splitting the final season of “Mad Men” over two years was a big mistake on the part of AMC. It worked for “Breaking Bad” for a number of organic reasons that “Mad Men” doesn’t have the benefit of.

  5. The closing minutes of Northern Exposure set to Iris Dement’s heart-wrenching Our Town still make me mist up.

  6. WORST FINALE: HIMYM
    BEST FINALES: Six Feet Under, Friday Night Lights, Breaking Bad, Lost, Fargo

  7. I always remember the last “Lucy Desi Comedy Hour,” which was the last I Love Lucy episode. Their divorce proceedings began the day after the episode wrapped. Desi says something like: “Being with Lucy is a lot of trouble, but it sure has been a lot of fun.” It was so sad, the cast and crew could barely hold it together.

  8. I dont know what everyone’s problem with the HIMYM ending is. Did you people seriously think for a second that he wouldn’t end up with Robin? The entire series used every convention of television romance to lead you by the hand to that inevitable conclusion. Do you really think it would have been better if he lived happily ever after with some character that was barely in the series?

    1. Then the show shouldn’t have been called How I Met Your Mother, but… How I Met the Tramp I replaced your mother with. Geez. One of the worst endings on television, ever, and it made the show look in retrospect to be the story of a selfish white group of whiners, led by a self-centered jack ass, telling the story of how he ended up with the woman he loved all along, once the one he fathered kids with was out of the way.

    1. Just for curiosity, have you ever heard of reruns? Just for curiosity, while you sit in you grandmother’s basement typing on a 15 year old Dell, have you ever contemplated how you’ve wasted your life as a fanboy who only wants to be sated by ComicCon?

    2. What a gratuitously useless snotball little comment. If Benten32 had actually been at the final Lucy episode, how cool would that be. Your mentality is what tv is targeted at these days and that’s why tv is dead [and it is dead - a few cable shows that a sliver of loudmouth fans watch is not a "golden age."]

      Btw, I’m in the target demo and I loved the Lucy reference. TV these days is so depressingly bad it’s always nice to be reminded of greatness, and thank goodness there’s always Lucy to watch.

      Mary Tyler Moore and other past great shows mentioned would not get made today. They’d be too worried about the useless younger demo – you know, the demo that has no money to buy all the advertised stuff on tv. What an irrational system. Great shows pulls in all demos just as those past great shows did.

  9. You are the only person who thought the ending of True Detective was good. I love that you can show off your pretentiousness, but philosophy aside, the finale showed the writer never had a plan and that they were crappy detectives all along.

    1. glad I’m not alone…. and seriously a 1 season story is being touted for ending a series well. It’s a long… well OVER long mediocre movie

  10. NYPD Blue had a great finale. Having Sipowicz become the head of his squad from where he was when the Series began. Fantastic.

  11. Seeing as how everyone’s doing this, I figured I’d chime in:

    Best Series Finales: The Sopranos, The Wire, Friday Night Lights, Breaking Bad

    Worst: Haven’t seen enough bad TV, but I reckon True Blood will be up there.

  12. Thanks for the trip down TV memory lane. I forgot how much I enjoyed watching NBC’s Homicide (I lived in Maryland back then), but the best series finale ever for me will always be FRIDAY NIGHT LIGHTS. Period.

  13. Yeah. You are definitely forgetting The Shield which, for my money, is the best series ending of all time. It remains criminally overlooked as always.

  14. How can you not mention the St. Elsewhere finale? The Newhard finale was heavily influenced by it.

  15. Congratulations remembering a final episode of any show.
    Thanks for the great article and summary of show endings.

  16. Best: Six Feet Under – I don’t think this one will ever be topped
    Worst: Dexter – an embarrassment

  17. The Glades was a horrible ending, of course, they did not know they were ending the shoe. They could have at least had an ending!

Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,192 other followers