EMMYS: Familiar Faces Fill Drama Acting Categories, Again

The competition in the drama lead actor and actress races is notable for how little it has changed since last year and, yet, how much it has changed. In each of the categories, four of the six nominees are returning to do battle. On the male side, we have Bryan Cranston, Jon Hamm, Kevin Spacey and last year’s winner Jeff Daniels duking it out again, while on the female side Michelle Dockery, Kerry Washington, Robin Wright and Claire Danes—the back-to-back winner in 2012 and 2013—are back in the race. The interesting thing in both contests is that the contenders who weren’t in the race last year have frontrunner Image (2) Awardsline-logo_use-this-one__140529211810-275x38.jpg for post 738599status. The Good Wife’s Julianna Margulies is back after inexplicably being passed over for a nomination last year. Most pundits agree that the 10-time nominee and past winner delivered her best work ever, and expect her to make a trip to the winner’s circle. Both Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey created waves when HBO decided that their eight-episode runs on True Detective constituted entry into the drama series acting race, rather than miniseries/movie, where everyone originally thought they would land. Their inclusion has been a big upset, especially because they both are vying for lead honors. Potential nominees such as The Americans’ Matthew Rhys, Master of Sex’s Michael Sheen and Downton Abbey’s Hugh Bonneville, among others, were shunted aside to make room for the HBO carpetbaggers. With wins in most of the precursor races, McConaughey is widely considered the favorite. It’s been an interesting turn of events for these categories, and here’s how they stack up.

Lead Actor in a Drama Series

Bryan Cranston Familiar Faces in Emmy Acting NominationsBryan Cranston, Breaking Bad, AMC
Although he won the Emmy in this category for the first three seasons of the landmark series, and picked up another as a producer last year, Cranston has sentiment on his side, with the chance that voters might reward his stunning work in the final season with yet another acting statuette. The only thing standing in his way is McConaughey.

jeffdaniels1Jeff Daniels, The Newsroom, HBO
Daniels long has been an underappreciated and under-awarded actor. That’s why it was such a bona fide shocker last year when he won in this category on his first ever nomination, and against stiff competition. Due to the tough stakes again this year, many thought he wouldn’t even get a nomination for the show’s second season. Here he is, but again as a longshot.

Jon Hamm, Mad Men, AMC
This is Hamm’s seventh nomination for his signature role as Don Draper. Unfortunately, it’s likely to be his seventh loss. Perhaps Hamm’s brilliant performance, week in and week out, is too subtle for voters. Next year, which will mark Mad Men’s series end, might be Hamm’s time in the sun, especially since Cranston and McConaughey won’t be factors.

true detective finaleWoody Harrelson, True Detective, HBO
Harrelson is an Emmy favorite and this is his 8th nomination overall, with one win in 1989 for Cheers. He is way overdue for more serious recognition, especially considering he brilliantly went toe-to-toe against McConaughey in True Detective. But even Harrelson seems to think he knows who is going to win—and it isn’t him.

Matthew McConaughey, True Detective, HBO
After winning the Oscar for Dallas Buyers Club in March, McConaughey is poised to become the first male actor to win both an Oscar and Emmy in the same year since George C. Scott did in 1971. The only drawback is that he was only in eight episodes of this show, making for a one-time arc that voters might feel isn’t as deserving of an award as a regular series star.

Kevin Spacey Familiar Faces in Emmy Acting NominationsKevin Spacey, House of Cards, Netflix
I was convinced Spacey was going to win last year for his first time out for this breakthrough Netflix series, so the loss to Daniels was unexpected. Sophomore familiarity and a lack of the same level of heat means Spacey has a bigger mountain to climb this time. He probably won’t be scaling the peak in 2014.

The Winner: Matthew McConaughey

Lead Actress in a Drama Series

Lizzy Caplan as Virginia Johnson in Masters of SexLizzy Caplan, Masters of Sex, Showtime
Truly unforgettable in a new Showtime series full of promise, Caplan has been gaining quite a following in her first season opposite veteran actor Michael Sheen who, sadly, didn’t get an Emmy nom. As an unknown factor in this race and a newcomer to the Emmy competition, Caplan could be a dark horse; her work on the show is that good.

Episode 403Claire Danes, Homeland, Showtime
For a while, it seemed as if Danes just couldn’t lose. After all, she was a winner in this category for Homeland’s first two seasons (the second of which was subpar at best), as well as a 2010 winner in the mini/movie category for Temple Grandin. But TV Academy members might be growing weary of Miss Danes and want to look elsewhere for their votes.

Image (1) DOWNTON-ABBEY-S-3-DEBUT__140106161113.jpg for post 659154Michelle Dockery, Downton Abbey, PBS
This is Dockery’s third consecutive nomination for her role in Downton; only Maggie Smith has been recognized more for the British drama. Many thought this was a down season for Downton, so it seems unlikely that Dockery has the amount of heat needed to crush this year’s competition.

Julianna Margulies, Familiar Faces in Emmy Acting NominationsJulianna Margulies, The Good Wife, CBS
When Margulies latches onto a series role voters like, she’s usually showered with Emmy love. She won her first Emmy in 1995 for ER and followed it with five more nods. This is her fourth nomination for The Good Wife to go with a win in 2011. Strangely, she missed the nomination cut last season but has come roaring back with her most talked about year ever.

KERRY WASHINGTON, COLUMBUS SHORT (BACKGROUND)Kerry Washington, Scandal, ABC
There are very few shows hotter on network television than ABC’s Scandal. With her second consecutive acting nomination, Washington is looking to make history in as diverse a lineup of acting nominees as the Emmys have seen in a while. Look for her to upset Margulies and take the prize if voters tend to agree with the show’s many fans.

Robin Wright Familiar Faces in Acting Emmy NominationsRobin Wright, House of Cards, Netflix
Wright has been gaining lots of steam since her first nomination in this category last year. She even won a Golden Globe for her role in this political thriller and could be ripe to outshine costar Kevin Spacey at the Emmys, too, since her character’s arc has been getting juicier and juicier. I would not be shocked to see Wright triumph on August 25.

The Winner: Julianna Margulies

 

Supporting Actor in a Drama Series

jim carterJim Carter, Downton Abbey (PBS)
A well-deserved third nomination for one of Downton’s most reliably interesting characters is probably all Carter will get in the category this year.

Josh CharlesJosh Charles, The Good Wife (CBS)
In one of the TV season’s most shocking moments, Charles’ Will Gardner was killed off, as was the actor’s run on the show, although he still is directing episodes. Dying in this case was a good thing, because Emmy voters took notice. With his second nom, Charles could pull an upset.

big GAME OF THRONES PETER DINKLAGE PICPeter Dinklage, Game of Thrones (HBO)
Dinklage—with his fourth nomination and previous win for this role—seems to have a lock on Emmy voters’ hearts. It doesn’t seem likely, though, that he will have trophy bookends any time soon.

mandy patinkinMandy Patinkin, Homeland (Showtime)
Patinkin is one of those rare actors who is good in everything—he is a key reason to keep watching Homeland—but this is not his year.

Aaron Paul Familiar Faces in Acting Emmy NominationsAaron Paul, Breaking Bad (AMC)
Five nominations and two wins just are not enough to honor the singular creation that is Paul’s Jesse Pinkman. The actor’s perf in the final season was dazzling, intense and positively operatic in its scope.

Jon VoightJon Voight, Ray Donovan (Showtime)
Voight already has won a Golden Globe for his first season on this show, and an Emmy could follow for this actor’s actor.

The Winner: Aaron Paul

 

Supporting Actress in a Drama Series

The Good WifeChristine Baranski, The Good Wife (CBS)
The actors branch loves her and has showered Baranski with 12 nominations over the years, but only one win, and for this show. Anything is possible, just not likely this time around.

joanne froggattJoanne Froggatt, Downton Abbey (PBS)
Emmy voters love their Brits, so it’s no surprise Froggatt is back for a second nomination. She likely will find herself cancelled out with Smith for the win.

'Game of Thrones', 'Breaking Bad' A Fierce Year for Dramas at EmmysAnna Gunn, Breaking Bad (AMC)
Gunn finally broke Maggie Smith’s stranglehold in the category when she won for the first time last year, and justice was served. But Bad’s prior season was nothing compared to the histrionics and human drama of the series’ final eight episodes. No one else comes close here.

lean headeyLena Headey, Game of Thrones (HBO)
If anyone could upset Gunn it is Headey, earning her first nomination as Cersei Lannister and making every moment count on this large-scale drama.

hendricksChristina Hendricks, Mad Men (AMC)
In seven seasons, not a single actor has won an Emmy for Mad Men. Shame on you, TV Academy. Hendricks’ performances always are deserving, but the actress probably has given up hoping for a win. There’s always next year to give Hendricks a big sendoff into TV history.

maggie smithMaggie Smith, Downton Abbey (PBS)
The Dowager Countess of Grantham, in the hands of this great Dame, is a formidable character, but Smith, a three-time Emmy-winner, didn’t have the kind of material that makes Gunn so strong this year.

The Winner: Anna Gunn

  1. As good as the ratings are for Scandal, from reading the fan communities, most actually don’t think Kerry should win this year. Season 3 just wasn’t at all a good year for her character. It would be criminal if she were to pull off a win over some of these other actresses.

    1. What does that have to do with winning? Homeland was terrible last season but Danes could still win. Both Danes and Washington submitted their best episodes and have a strong chance of winning. Wright and Margulies did not submit well and could lose out based on their episode submission. Caplan is a longshot.

  2. If the Emmy voters watch Ozymandias I truly wouldnt be able to understand how Bryan Cranston could lose? He was amazing the Entire episode.

  3. I’m surprised McConaughey didn’t enter ‘Who Goes There’. It was his best episode: old Rust, young Rust, middle-aged Rust and Rust undercover. Plus, his acting in the 6 minute tracking shot was a stunning accomplishment.

  4. ONE Talent Of Color in the whole lot. ONE. For an Industry that is supposedly progressive, liberal, and open-minded, this is effin shameful.

    1. Kerry Washington is more than just the color of her skin. She deserves more from you than that. And you could say the same for all the actors and actresses nominated this year. Please don’t judge a person’s worthiness of a nomination on the color of their skin.

      However, if you insist on summing people up as minorities, then you should be delighted to know that Peter Dinklage (little person), John Voit (old) and Maggie Smith (even older) managed to score nominations this year.

      I’d also like to know which of these talented actors and actresses that were nominated you feel did not give worthy performances and who you would replace them with that better fits your quota. Care to share your thoughts?

      1. well said. its true that these categories do have minorities . but they aren’t always what you think they are .

      2. Can you read? Where did I write that the nominees did not give worthy performances? Where did I write anything about replacements to fit quotas? Care to share you ignorance?

        1. You’re upset at the lack of people of color who received nominations this year. My question is, 1) who do you feel is a person of color who deserved a nomination this year that didn’t receive one and 2) Which of the already nominated actors and actresses do you feel should not have received a nomination so that your person(s) of color could take their spot?

          You left such an accusatory comment and these are perfectly reasonable follow up questions.

  5. Still rankles me that Scott Wilson and Melissa McBride from The Walking Dead failed to get nominated for their incredible work last season. Of course, this is coming from the only people who watch TV that don’t realize what Tatiana Maslany is doing on Orphan Black. And while Aaron Paul has been outstanding during Breaking Bad’s run, he didn’t have as much to do for those last episodes, while Patinkin really carried Homeland last season.

  6. I don’t think Carter’s nomination was well-deserved nor is his character all that interesting. He’s a stock character: the proper English butler with a soft side, more comic relief than anything else. He beat out a number of more deserving actors in this category, which is more the pity given that just as in the past, he has absolutely zero chance of winning. The voters were right to shut out Bonneville, though, given that he did next to nothing in this season of Downton.

    If any actors from the show deserved to be nominated, they were Rob James-Collier and Allen Leech. But for S3, not for S4 which was a disappointment in general and provided no decent writing for either of them.

Comments are closed.